Can You Freeze Eggnog?

Freeze Eggnog

Hello, dear readers! As we bask in the festive ambiance, one of the season’s most iconic beverages comes to mind: eggnog. Ah, the creamy richness, the comforting blend of spices, and that slight hint of nutmeg—it’s what winter dreams are made of.

But what do you do when you’ve whipped up a big batch of this creamy goodness and realize you have more eggnog than you can handle? Do you let it go to waste? Definitely not!

Today, we’re tackling an important question that could save your holiday season: Can you freeze eggnog? Stick with me, and you’ll find out not only if you can freeze it but also how to do it the right way, how long it lasts in the freezer, and even some creative ways to use it once it’s thawed.

Can You Freeze Eggnog?

The short answer is yes, you can absolutely freeze eggnog!

Freezing is a fantastic way to extend the life of this holiday favorite. It also allows you to enjoy eggnog even when the holidays are over—just imagine sipping on some delicious, homemade eggnog in the middle of July!

However, the success of freezing eggnog depends on a couple of factors such as its ingredients and how you go about the freezing process. Don’t worry; I’ll walk you through all of it.

How To Freeze Eggnog?

Step 1: Choose The Right Eggnog

First, let’s talk about the eggnog you’re planning to freeze. If it’s store-bought, make sure to check the expiration date. Fresh is always better. Homemade eggnog tends to freeze well, but make sure you’ve mixed it thoroughly for a consistent texture.

Step 2: Portion It Out

Don’t just toss the whole jug into the freezer. Divide your eggnog into manageable portions. You might want to use zip-top freezer bags or airtight containers. If you’re like me and enjoy eggnog in your coffee, freeze them in ice cube trays for easy use.

Step 3: Label and Date

Trust me, you don’t want to play the guessing game when it comes to frozen food. Use a permanent marker to write down what it is and when you froze it.

Step 4: Leave Some Space

Eggnog will expand as it freezes. Make sure to leave about an inch of space at the top of your container to avoid any messy overflows.

Step 5: Store It Right

Place your portioned and labeled eggnog at the back of the freezer where the temperature is most stable. Avoid putting it in the door shelves, as temperatures there can fluctuate.

How Long Can You Freeze Eggnog?

The freezer can be a lifesaver, but it’s not a time machine. While freezing extends the life of your eggnog, it won’t keep indefinitely. Typically, you can store frozen eggnog for up to six months. Beyond that point, you may notice a change in its texture and flavor.

If you’ve marked the date on the container (as you should!), it’ll be easy to keep track. You can even set a reminder on your phone. Trust me, you don’t want to stumble upon a mysterious container of eggnog during your next year’s spring cleaning.

How To Defrost Eggnog?

Okay, you’ve successfully frozen your eggnog. Great job! But what’s the best way to bring it back to its liquid glory?

Step 1: Thaw in the Fridge

The safest way to thaw frozen eggnog is in the refrigerator. This can take anywhere from several hours to a full day, depending on the quantity.

Step 2: Stir or Blend

Frozen eggnog may separate into different layers. A quick stir or even a blitz in a blender will bring it back to a consistent texture.

Step 3: Taste Test

Before serving or using your thawed eggnog, give it a quick taste to make sure the flavor has held up. If something tastes off, it’s better to err on the side of caution and discard it.

Step 4: Heat It Up

If you prefer your eggnog warm, you can heat it on the stove over low heat. Remember to keep stirring to prevent any scalding at the bottom of the pan.

Do Eggnog Freeze Well?

I know you’re curious: Does eggnog maintain its creamy, dreamy quality after a stint in the freezer? For the most part, yes, but with a slight catch. The texture may be a bit grainier than fresh eggnog, particularly if it contains alcohol. The good news? A quick blend or stir can usually restore its original consistency.

If you’ve used a high-fat recipe for your homemade eggnog, the result after thawing will be even better. Fats freeze well and help maintain the texture of the thawed product. So don’t skimp on the good stuff; it pays off in the long run!

Can You Refreeze Eggnog?

We’ve all been there—thawing more food than we can consume. But when it comes to eggnog, it’s generally not advisable to refreeze what you’ve thawed. Refreezing can degrade the texture significantly and may also increase the risk of bacterial growth.

If you find yourself with more thawed eggnog than you can use, why not try one of the creative ways to use it up that I’ll share next?

Creative Ways to Use Eggnog

Just because your eggnog has been in the freezer doesn’t mean it has to be relegated to a simple beverage again. Oh no, there are plenty of tasty and inventive ways to give it a second life!

1. Eggnog Smoothies

Blend your thawed eggnog with some fruits like bananas and a touch of cinnamon for a scrumptious smoothie. Trust me, it’s a game-changer!

2. Eggnog Pancakes

Replace the milk in your pancake recipe with thawed eggnog. The flavors blend wonderfully, making your breakfast a real treat.

3. Eggnog Ice Cream

If you’ve got an ice cream maker, churn that thawed eggnog into a delicious ice cream. Top it with some crushed gingerbread cookies for an extra festive touch.

4. Eggnog Lattes

For a delicious twist on your morning coffee, swap out your usual creamer with thawed eggnog. It’s like the holidays all over again!

5. Eggnog French Toast

Dip your bread slices into a mixture of eggnog, cinnamon, and eggs for a French toast that’s out of this world.

6. Eggnog Baking

Use eggnog as a substitute for milk or water in your favorite cake or muffin recipes. The result is a moist, flavorful treat with a hint of the holidays.


Freezing eggnog is not only possible, but it’s also a fantastic way to extend your holiday joy. As long as you follow the proper steps for freezing, thawing, and even creatively using your eggnog, there’s no reason to let a single drop go to waste. Remember, the freezer is your friend, but make sure you treat it (and your eggnog) with the respect they deserve.

Now go on, spread some cheer and freeze that eggnog. You’ll thank yourself later!


Can I freeze store-bought eggnog?

Yes, you can. Just make sure to check the expiration date and follow the steps mentioned for freezing.

Is it safe to drink thawed eggnog?

As long as you’ve properly frozen and thawed the eggnog and it has been stored for no longer than six months, it should be safe to drink.

Can I freeze eggnog in its original container?

It’s better to transfer the eggnog into airtight containers or zip-top bags that allow for some expansion during freezing.

Does eggnog’s taste change after freezing?

While the basic flavor profile remains the same, there might be a slight change in texture. A quick stir or blend usually fixes this.

What can I do with leftover thawed eggnog?

From eggnog lattes to eggnog French toast, there are plenty of creative ways to use up any leftover thawed eggnog.

Can I add alcohol to thawed eggnog?

Yes, you can, but keep in mind that adding alcohol may alter the texture slightly. It’s always best to do a taste test first.

Richard Lawley Avatar

Written by:

You’ll also love